Jump to content







Photo
- - - - -

Battlefronts

Posted by Autumnpuma , 14 November 2007 · 40 views

Soon all us dedicated fans of F1 will see two pivotal battles taking place over the very essence of the Formula World Championship. The first battle is between McLaren and BMW/Williams. Who wins or loses isn't as important as what happens to the Driver's Championship as a result. If two drivers are excluded from the Brazilian result, Lewis Hamilton will be the points leader for 2007. With that, he will become the 2007 Driver's Champion. Period. There is no debate, no wiggle room, no fancy excuses. The point's leader wins and it's really that simple. To anyone arguing that it isn't fair to Kimi, that Kimi deserves it more, that Kimi won it on-track, I would respond with a stern 'grow up and face the real world'. World Champions are crowned by a points lead, not by popular opinion.

The second battle will also be fought in the courts. There are only two acceptable outcomes for the 'Renault Spy Scandal'. The first would see Renault hit with the exact punishment McLaren recieved. The second would be to let Renault off with a lesser punishment and re-visit the McLaren judgement and reduce that to match Renault's. I'll not get into the details of the Renault vs. McLaren scandals; they are the same. The punishment should be the same.

On these two battles rests my dedication to F1. Any deviation from what I've said above would see me turn to other forms of motorsport because F1 will have ceased to be what it has always been. We, the fans, over the long years have had to tolerate trials and tribulations, and each fan must decide for him (or her) self where that 'line' of tolerance will be drawn. I draw my line here.

It's easy to retreat from this and pull on a mask of apathy or strike a pose of cynicism disguised as wisdom. It's far harder to admit when something you are an avid fan of is no longer worthy of that fanship.




1: I agree.  It would be a really lame way to decide the title, but if Lewis won, he won...it'll be awkward for Kimi, but I'm sure Kimi is man enough (or has enough alcohol) to deal with losing this way.  If he wasn't, would you put him in F1?  Sure, no one expects this to happen, but it does happen, and if the drivers aren't prepared for it, then they aren't 100% prepared for the sport.

2: I don't even know what the Renault scandal is, so I'll leave this one up to the experts.

3: I drew my line a while ago, but I mildly follow over news articles that aren't too long and are inevitable because I go to websites that cover multiple forms of motorsports.

4: I agree.  I was an avid fan of NASCAR...watching it die and just having to leave it was not easy to do, but it had to be done.  I hope for the sake of you weirdos that F1 doesn't get to the point where you have to leave it.
  • Report
Thanks for the reply, Eric. I hear you. I've had a long run with F1, and alot of fun with it over the years, but if it becomes something far removed from what I love, I won't watch it much. I'll keep tabs on it and casually follow the races, but my focus will shift to more grass-roots motorsports or sportscar-ish. I can easily get my fix of open-wheel with ChampCar.
  • Report
I just hope the verdict is clear-cut, as in if the relevant cars are disqualified, then Hamilton should be moved up. As much as I think that the title belongs to Kimi, if he 'lost' it, I wouldn't quit on F1.

Anyway, I don't think Lewis will be made champion, it would be bad for pretty much everyone's image - and F1 loves looking at itself in the mirror.

I don't even want to talk about the Renault spy scandal.
  • Report
To me, image is irrelevant. The points leader, whomever that is, takes the crown. To do anything other than that is to say "We are not Formula 1, we are an arbitrary popularity contest". I will not watch a popularity contest.
  • Report
>



^ I disagree.
There has been stuff like this before (Herman Lang in 39, James Hunt in 76; numerous spy scandals too) and there will be again. No problem, that's just the way it is.
  • Report
Cynicism is a poor excuse for wisdom.
  • Report

monza gorilla
Nov 17 2007 02:14 PM
But much easier to come by.

Having said that, I do agree with you, Mike. I have a strange compulsion to watch sports cars these days. And touring cars. And an almost overwhelming urge to fire bomb the FIA HQ. I'd never considered it before, in any detail, but read Mike Lawrence's article on Pitpass titled House of Cards. He has a point.
  • Report
Good post Mike.  As you know, I'm kind of resigned to the fact that F1 is highly imperfect.
  • Report
Russ, I read Mike's article on pitpass and it's easy to agree with him...mostly because he's telling the truth!

It appears as though the FIA have sidestepped the battle between McLaren, BMW and Williams by claiming that McLaren didn't have the right to even line up it's troops for the battle. Rather odd, that. I suppose it's McLaren's own fault by claiming that they didn't want Hamilton to win the title if two cars were thrown out. With that kind of argument, it's easy to see why the FIA found that McLaren wasn't an 'interested party'. Would have been better all around if McLaren has said that they want the title....then the case would have been heard. Ah well, crisis averted I suppose. Now for the next battle...
  • Report
Apparently the WMSC has found Renault guilty of breaching the same article as McLaren....but has imposed no penalty. So, the battle is finally over. It's time to leave F1 until sanity is restored and it's governed properly. My focus will shift to more stable forms of motorsport with the occasional viewing of F1 if I get the chance.

Adieu dear friends.
  • Report

monza gorilla
Dec 07 2007 01:29 PM

Autumnpuma, on Dec 6 2007, 06:29 PM, said:

Apparently the WMSC has found Renault guilty of breaching the same article as McLaren....but has imposed no penalty. So, the battle is finally over. It's time to leave F1 until sanity is restored and it's governed properly. My focus will shift to more stable forms of motorsport with the occasional viewing of F1 if I get the chance.

Adieu dear friends.
Ditto. I've had enough. Except for one upcoming humungous blog entry by way of a parting gift. Over and out.
  • Report
I should say that the 'adieu good friends' was meant to apply to the F1 establishment far more than everyone on this forum! I shall pop in from time to time, but as my interest in F1 has dropped to nil, I forsee my postings dropping as well. Russ, as always, I look forward to your blog entry.
  • Report

June 2013

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819 20 2122
23242526272829
30      

Recent Entries

Recent Comments

Disclaimer

This blog contains my personal views and does not represent TotalF1.com in any way.


This website is unofficial and is not associated in any way with the Formula One group of companies. F1, FORMULA ONE, FORMULA 1, FIA FORMULA ONE WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP, GRAND PRIX and related marks are trade marks of Formula One Licensing B.V.