Clicky

Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

yurp

First Total F1 Debate

By yurp, in F1 Discussions

Recommended Posts

yurp    0

yurp
Posted

PLEASE DO NOT POST DIRECTLY IN THIS THREAD UNLESS YOU ARE A MEMBER OF A DEBATING TEAM OR A JURY MEMBER - ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE DEBATERS SHOULD BE SENT TO ANDRES (QUIET ONE) BY PM.

THANK YOU.

Question - "Does Webber deserve a Red Bull?"

Moderator:

Andres (Quite One)

Duties:

Keep debaters in line - Andres, you know how to do this. Just jump in if you need to, but try to avoid it otherwise.

Receive questions in your message inbox from other users and choose which to put to the debaters. (see Format below)

Teams, picked out of hat (coffee cup) - leaders in bold...

Yes Team:

The Professor (wimp)

Argento Reloaded (new team leader)

Kopite Girl

JHS (new team member)

No Team:

Cavallino

AutumnPuma

BradSpeedMan

Questioners:

Anyone (Jury members and opposing teams may also send questions for Andres to ask)

NB - QUESTIONS FROM QUESTIONERS SHOULD BE SENT TO ANDRES BY PM NOT ADDED TO THREAD DIRECTLY

This way Andres can moderate the questions and order them well in a single post for each team. (see Format below)

Jury:

Monza

AleHop

Max Mosley

piquettheterrible2

Tommy

We will have a jury and a public poll - The jury will offer their verdicts in a post each - the poll will be there for anyone to have a vote at the end.

EDIT - can teams and the jury post in their colour too so the thread is easy to read?

green for Yes Team, red for No Team, pink for Jury, blue for Andres.

Format:

1) Open thread - set starting date for debate 4 days later (give teams a chance to prepare) :thbup:

Part 1

2) Introduction from Andres

3) Yes Team Leader opening statement

4) No Team Leader opening statement

5) Yes Team 2nd member argument

6) No Team 2nd member argument

7) Yes Team 3rd member argument

8) No Team 3rd member argument

9) Yes Team Leader summing up

10) No Team Leader summing up

Part 2

11) Andres - questions for Yes Team (received via PM from questioners, moderated and ordered by Andres)

12) Yes Team Leader, 2nd member and 3rd member rebuttals to questions. (1 post each)

13) Andres - questions for No Team (received via PM from questioners, moderated and ordered by Andres)

14) No Team Leader, 2nd member and 3rd member rebuttals to questions. (1 post each)

15) Andres calls on jury and sums up arguments from Teams (impartial - NOT judgement)

16) Jury Verdicts (5 posts, one from each jury member including judgement - Yes or No win)

17) Andres pronunces winners according to jury verdict

18) Open poll (Public verdict)

Andres will make his introduction next on the 12th of May 2010.

Teams - get ready!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

AleHop    0

AleHop
Posted

OK

Hee hee I feel so naughty biggrin.gif Couldn't resist.

Ok? How can you agree that Webber doesn't deserve a Red Bull after such a brilliant win in Spain!!!! mad.gif

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Max Mosley    2

Max Mosley
Posted

OK

Hee hee I feel so naughty :D Couldn't resist.

:lol:

That made me laugh. A lot!

So this jury member reckons you have the best joke so far...

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

mikathegreat2    2

mikathegreat2
Posted

Ok? How can you agree that Webber doesn't deserve a Red Bull after such a brilliant win in Spain!!!! mad.gif

Agree with this post.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kopite Girl    0

Kopite Girl
Posted

Georgie, Argento - we need to get together to sort this out dudes. Do both of you have MSN?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

dribbler    6

dribbler
Posted

*dribbler opens door and sees the group sitting around naked in their clicky little mass debating sect. He closes the door.*

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

AleHop    0

AleHop
Posted

Maybe he wasn't thirsty? eusa_think.gif

At least you'll agree that he deserves an ice-cream. Raikkonen didn't need to be thirsty to have a Red Bull.

*dribbler opens door and sees the group sitting around naked in their clicky little mass debating sect. He closes the door.*

Grabthaw who had been sitting in the room in the dark shouts: "Hey, lemmee out!"

smile.gif

roll.gif

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Rainmaster    7

Rainmaster
Posted

Georgie, Argento - we need to get together to sort this out dudes. Do both of you have MSN?

I'm honoured to be chosen, but, I'm going to have to opt out of this particular debate! Like I said in my original post on this matter, I'm happy to step in every now and then with my 2 cents, but what I meant to imply was that I can't really be involved in a proper debate at the moment (at least not in a format where I'm relied on to lead it or post anything useful) - reason being I'm too busy with various things and can't guarantee I'll be on the forum that much.

Sorry guys and girls!

Nevertheless I will follow it with interest and will hopefully be chosen for a future debate. Good luck all.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

yurp    0

yurp
Posted

I'm honoured to be chosen, but, I'm going to have to opt out of this particular debate! Like I said in my original post on this matter, I'm happy to step in every now and then with my 2 cents, but what I meant to imply was that I can't really be involved in a proper debate at the moment (at least not in a format where I'm relied on to lead it or post anything useful) - reason being I'm too busy with various things and can't guarantee I'll be on the forum that much.

Sorry guys and girls!

Nevertheless I will follow it with interest and will hopefully be chosen for a future debate. Good luck all.

Okay george - I'll swap you for someone else and let them know.

Inevetibly - it seems like the attempt to raise the tone failed dismally at the first hurdle.:o shock.

Let's see if (once Andres makes his intro) we can steer the thread back on track.

I think this is a great idea Steph's had and it'd be a shame for us just to revert to our usual idiocy (I'll mention no names).

*coughGurtrudetheHornSuckercough*

PS - Dribs - I had managed to refrain from using the massdebater joke for a whole week - you just had to do it didn't you. :lol:

Let's hope after Andres' intro we can have a decent debate.

Meanwhile any posts can be put in Steph's debate idea thread, or alternatively, shoved sideways up your rectum :P

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kopite Girl    0

Kopite Girl
Posted

*dribbler opens door and sees the group sitting around naked in their clicky little mass debating sect. He closes the door.*

Me, naked. With this lot. You're kidding right?

Mass clique? Well, stop being a pussy and put your name down and get naked too. Thank you, that is all.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

dribbler    6

dribbler
Posted

Me, naked. With this lot. You're kidding right?

Mass clique? Well, stop being a pussy and put your name down and get naked too. Thank you, that is all.

I never got invited. *sniffing and violin music can be heard*. But I am naked.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Autumnpuma    0

Autumnpuma
Posted

I think this is a great idea Steph's had and it'd be a shame for us just to revert to our usual idiocy (I'll mention no names).

I like our usual idiocy. It's comfortable.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Medilloni    6

Medilloni
Posted

I like our usual idiocy. It's comfortable.

Ssshhhhh, the grown ups are talking downstairs, I think they're going to argue again.... :lol:

Agreed btw Mike!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kopite Girl    0

Kopite Girl
Posted

I never got invited. *sniffing and violin music can be heard*. But I am naked.

I told you to let the coke sniffing violin player go. Its against the law to kidnap someone.

Are you in or out?

I have just left myself wide open to remarks with that one.

And that.

So?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

yurp    0

yurp
Posted

I never got invited. *sniffing and violin music can be heard*. But I am naked.

:lol:

I like our usual idiocy. It's comfortable.

:D true true

oh well.

*reengages idiot mode*

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Medilloni    6

Medilloni
Posted

If its any comfort, I didn't realise it had been switched off :P:D :D :D

Bugger off Chris, the humanoid known as 'Adam' hasn't been programmed with 'idiot mode' yet, the team are still trying to fix the Seriously Troubled & Rabid Android Geek Syndrome glitch in his circuitronics thingamabobby.

:P

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

yurp    0

yurp
Posted

Bugger off Chris, the humanoid known as 'Adam' hasn't been programmed with 'idiot mode' yet, the team are still trying to fix the Seriously Troubled & Rabid Android Geek Syndrome glitch in his circuitronics thingamabobby.

:P

error #672: does not compute

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kopite Girl    0

Kopite Girl
Posted

Guys. Seriously. Stop f*cking about now. Especially you, Chris.

There's a multitude of other threads you could p**s about in. Adam, start a new one. Bruce or Ecap, lock this one.

I'd really like to see if it could work. Yes, I know I got caught up too - but you're taking the p**s now. Behave.

Anybody dares to put a smart arse remark after this comment has got it coming to them and I mean it.

You've been told. Don't p**s me off.

Thats all.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Go To Topic Listing
×
×
  • Create New...